Skip to main content

UNITED STATES · USD DEPOSITS

High-yield savings vs. a 1-year CD

Compare the interest you could keep if you need your money early or can leave it for a full year.

When will you need the money?

If you need it early

Interest you could keep

Both scenarios use the same deposit. Amounts are before tax, after any estimated early withdrawal penalty.

$25,000.00
Early withdrawal

Take it out after 6 months

  • High-yield savings$396.85
  • 1-year CD$277.59

High-yield savings keeps $119.26 more

CD: $550.20 earned − $272.61 early withdrawal penalty.

At CD maturity

Wait the full 12 months

  • High-yield savings$800.00
  • 1-year CD$1,112.50

1-year CD keeps $312.50 more

CD: no early withdrawal penalty at maturity.

These estimates use the dated rates below. The savings rate is held constant for the example and can change. Actual interest and penalties can differ.

What changes when you need the cash?

Ally Savings Account

No fixed term
3.20% APYRate used in this estimate ·

Ally allows withdrawals by transfer or check. Some withdrawals and transfers count toward a limit of 10 per statement cycle.

Ally withdrawal rules

Capital One 360 CD

12-month term
4.45% APYRate used in this estimate ·

Capital One generally requires you to close the CD to withdraw principal before maturity. Its 12-month CD charges three months’ interest for early withdrawal.

Capital One CD terms

Compare more deposit types

See the same deposit amount and selected early month alongside no-penalty CDs and money market accounts.

Open the full deposit comparison